Silent Butler

March 6, 2010 10:42 am | silver antiques

How close is Phantom of the Opera (2004) musical to the original 1925 version?

The question is self explanatory, but since I only saw parts and not all of the 1925 version, I was wondering how well it adapts the original story.
I'm a great fan of musicals, Gerard Butler, but also of the silent film era and Lon Chaney. Man was a genius when it came to acting and make up. So I wonder, how close are these two stories linked?
And also, in your personal opinion, which do you find better? ( I know it's different genres, but u have a preference!! )

About as close as the North Pole is to the South Pole. In that they both are at ends of the earth, have sub-zero temperatures, darkness for months on end, etc. But otherwise, thaaaaaat far apart.

Silver Antique Silent Butler Crumb Catcher 1883 Silver on Copper FB Rogers
Silver Antique Silent Butler Crumb Catcher 1883 Silver on Copper FB Rogers
$15.99
Time Remaining: 48m

Silver FORBES Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Forbes 925 Silver
Silver FORBES Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Forbes 925 Silver
$94.00
Time Remaining: 2h 41m
Buy It Now for only: $124.99

Finest Birks REGENCY Silver Plate Silent Butler ashtray w original wood handle
Finest Birks REGENCY Silver Plate Silent Butler ashtray w original wood handle
$95.95
Time Remaining: 3h 1m
Buy It Now for only: $95.95

EDWARDIAN DECO ERA STYLE HANDLED ROLLING SILENT BUTLER TABLE CRUMBER 1924 dated
EDWARDIAN DECO ERA STYLE HANDLED ROLLING SILENT BUTLER TABLE CRUMBER 1924 dated
$9.95
Time Remaining: 4h 32m

FB Rogers Silver Co 1883 Antique Signed Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Pan
FB Rogers Silver Co 1883 Antique Signed Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Pan
$9.00
Time Remaining: 5h 35m

Sheffield Silver Plate Silent Butler Crumb Pan
Sheffield Silver Plate Silent Butler Crumb Pan
$125.00
Time Remaining: 5h 38m
Buy It Now for only: $125.00

Antique England Birks Regency Silver Plate Silent Butler ashtray or Bowl Vintage
Antique England Birks Regency Silver Plate Silent Butler ashtray or Bowl Vintage
$48.95
Time Remaining: 6h 22m
Buy It Now for only: $48.95

ANTIQUE SILVER SILENT BUTLER TABLE SERVING DISH
ANTIQUE SILVER SILENT BUTLER TABLE SERVING DISH
$39.50
Time Remaining: 7h 2m
Buy It Now for only: $39.50

SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER EG WEBSTER  SON
SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER EG WEBSTER SON
$27.00
Time Remaining: 17h 39m
Buy It Now for only: $40.00

Vntg LGOrnate Etched Lion Silver On Copper Silent Butler Ash Crumb Catcher Pan
Vntg LGOrnate Etched Lion Silver On Copper Silent Butler Ash Crumb Catcher Pan
$35.99
Time Remaining: 22h 3m

Vintage MAJOR AB ADVERSIS SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER WOOD HANDLE DISTRESSED
Vintage MAJOR AB ADVERSIS SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER WOOD HANDLE DISTRESSED
$9.47
Time Remaining: 22h 6m
Buy It Now for only: $12.38

Vintage Silent Butler Bristol Silver EPCA 102 Ash Crumb Tray VGUC
Vintage Silent Butler Bristol Silver EPCA 102 Ash Crumb Tray VGUC
$15.95
Time Remaining: 22h 54m
Buy It Now for only: $15.95

Forbes Silver Co Crumb Ash Collector Silent Butler With Lion Detail
Forbes Silver Co Crumb Ash Collector Silent Butler With Lion Detail
$18.00
Time Remaining: 1d 1h 4m
Buy It Now for only: $24.00

EDWARDIAN DECO ERA STYLE HANDLED ROLLING SILVER SILENT BUTLER TABLE CRUMBER
EDWARDIAN DECO ERA STYLE HANDLED ROLLING SILVER SILENT BUTLER TABLE CRUMBER
$289.00
Time Remaining: 1d 1h 18m
Buy It Now for only: $289.00

VINTAGE SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER
VINTAGE SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER
$19.99
Time Remaining: 1d 2h 32m

Silent Butler Solid Sterling Silver Miniature Vintage
Silent Butler Solid Sterling Silver Miniature Vintage
$175.00
Time Remaining: 1d 2h 52m
Buy It Now for only: $175.00

VINTAGE SILVER FOOTED SILENT BUTLER WONDERFUL CONDITION POLISHED IMMACULATE
VINTAGE SILVER FOOTED SILENT BUTLER WONDERFUL CONDITION POLISHED IMMACULATE
$19.95
Time Remaining: 1d 3h 15m
Buy It Now for only: $19.95

F B Rogers Silent Butler 6044
F B Rogers Silent Butler 6044
$12.00
Time Remaining: 1d 3h 26m
Buy It Now for only: $12.00

Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler and Forbes Silver Creamer
Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler and Forbes Silver Creamer
$59.00
Time Remaining: 1d 3h 30m
Buy It Now for only: $95.00

VTGMAJOR AB ADVERSIS BUTLER SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER WITH A WOODEN HANDLE
VTGMAJOR AB ADVERSIS BUTLER SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER WITH A WOODEN HANDLE
$34.28
Time Remaining: 1d 3h 51m
Buy It Now for only: $34.28

Oneida Silversmiths Silverplated Footed Silent Butler Vintage
Oneida Silversmiths Silverplated Footed Silent Butler Vintage
$24.95
Time Remaining: 1d 4h 58m
Buy It Now for only: $24.95

Silver plate silent butler crumb or dust pan
Silver plate silent butler crumb or dust pan
$0.99
Time Remaining: 1d 5h 4m

VINTAGE INTERNATIONAL SILVER CHIPPENDALE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER 657
VINTAGE INTERNATIONAL SILVER CHIPPENDALE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER 657
$9.99
Time Remaining: 1d 5h 27m
Buy It Now for only: $9.99

Vintage Silver Plate Covered Silent Butler with Wooden Handle Nice
Vintage Silver Plate Covered Silent Butler with Wooden Handle Nice
$8.95
Time Remaining: 1d 8h 10m

Vintage Brass MAJOR AB ADVERSIS Silent Butler plated
Vintage Brass MAJOR AB ADVERSIS Silent Butler plated
$19.50
Time Remaining: 1d 9h 53m
Buy It Now for only: $34.50

FB Rogers Silver Co Silver Plate Silent Butler 188 Crumb Catcher Lion Insignia
FB Rogers Silver Co Silver Plate Silent Butler 188 Crumb Catcher Lion Insignia
$29.95
Time Remaining: 1d 11h 12m
Buy It Now for only: $29.95

Vintage Silent Butler Crumb Catcher F B Rogers 1883 Silverplate Major AB Advers
Vintage Silent Butler Crumb Catcher F B Rogers 1883 Silverplate Major AB Advers
$30.00
Time Remaining: 1d 12h 4m
Buy It Now for only: $30.00

Vintage silver silent butler rose design
Vintage silver silent butler rose design
$21.25
Time Remaining: 1d 19h 3m
Buy It Now for only: $21.25

Antique Silent Butler
Antique Silent Butler
$19.99
Time Remaining: 1d 20h 21m

Vintage silver silent butler fish motif
Vintage silver silent butler fish motif
$23.80
Time Remaining: 1d 21h 5m
Buy It Now for only: $23.80

Vintage Silver Plate Silent Butler by Sheffield Silver Co Hell
Vintage Silver Plate Silent Butler by Sheffield Silver Co Hell
$4.99
Time Remaining: 1d 23h
Buy It Now for only: $9.99

SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLERS CRUMB CATCHERS LOT OF 2 INTERNATIONAL SILVER CO
SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLERS CRUMB CATCHERS LOT OF 2 INTERNATIONAL SILVER CO
$20.00
Time Remaining: 1d 23h 44m
Buy It Now for only: $20.00

VINTAGE THE SHEFFIELD SILVER CO USA 301 SILENT BUTLER ASH BUTLER CRUMB TRAY
VINTAGE THE SHEFFIELD SILVER CO USA 301 SILENT BUTLER ASH BUTLER CRUMB TRAY
$35.00
Time Remaining: 1d 23h 48m

Old Antique Silver Plate on Copper Silent Butler Kitchen Collectable Rare
Old Antique Silver Plate on Copper Silent Butler Kitchen Collectable Rare
$1.99
Time Remaining: 2d 7m
Buy It Now for only: $3.99

Vintage Friedman Silent Butler Silver Plated Crumb Tray w Dragon
Vintage Friedman Silent Butler Silver Plated Crumb Tray w Dragon
$8.99
Time Remaining: 2d 1h 49m
Buy It Now for only: $8.99

Sheffield Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher w Wooden Handle
Sheffield Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher w Wooden Handle
$7.00
Time Remaining: 2d 3h 44m

Antique Early 1900s Sheffield Ash Crumb Catcher or Silent Butler EPC 270
Antique Early 1900s Sheffield Ash Crumb Catcher or Silent Butler EPC 270
$349.00
Time Remaining: 2d 4h 52m
Buy It Now for only: $349.00

Silent Butler Silver on Copper Plate with Wooden Handle
Silent Butler Silver on Copper Plate with Wooden Handle
$35.00
Time Remaining: 2d 6h 26m
Buy It Now for only: $35.00

Vintage Leonard Silverplate Coffee Tea Service Set w EPNS Silent Butler tray
Vintage Leonard Silverplate Coffee Tea Service Set w EPNS Silent Butler tray
$75.00
Time Remaining: 2d 8h 50m

VINTAGE SILENT BUTLER POOLE SILVER COMPANY 75
VINTAGE SILENT BUTLER POOLE SILVER COMPANY 75
$20.00
Time Remaining: 2d 10h 2m

SHEFFIELD SILVER SILENT BUTLER CRUMB CATCHER W WOODEN HANDLE
SHEFFIELD SILVER SILENT BUTLER CRUMB CATCHER W WOODEN HANDLE
$18.84
Time Remaining: 2d 11h 34m
Buy It Now for only: $34.94

Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Made in USA
Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Made in USA
$14.99
Time Remaining: 2d 15h 32m
Buy It Now for only: $14.99

Vintage Silent Butler Crumb Brush and Tray Silver Plate Western Germany Quist
Vintage Silent Butler Crumb Brush and Tray Silver Plate Western Germany Quist
$24.99
Time Remaining: 2d 20h 34m

SILENT BUTLER OLD SHEFFIELD PLATE LION MARK ENGLAND
SILENT BUTLER OLD SHEFFIELD PLATE LION MARK ENGLAND
$99.99
Time Remaining: 2d 20h 47m

Vintage SILVER PLATED Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Pan By SHEFFIELD SILVER CO
Vintage SILVER PLATED Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Pan By SHEFFIELD SILVER CO
$15.00
Time Remaining: 2d 23h
Buy It Now for only: $15.00

Vintage Antique Silver on Copper Silent Butler Crumb Catcher w Wooden Handle
Vintage Antique Silver on Copper Silent Butler Crumb Catcher w Wooden Handle
$24.99
Time Remaining: 2d 23h 1m
Buy It Now for only: $24.99

ANTIQUE F B ROGERS SILVER PLATE WOODEN HANDLE 4 LEGS STANDING SILENT BUTLER
ANTIQUE F B ROGERS SILVER PLATE WOODEN HANDLE 4 LEGS STANDING SILENT BUTLER
$59.99
Time Remaining: 3d 15m
Buy It Now for only: $59.99

Vintage International Silver Chippendale Silent butler Crumber Silver Plate
Vintage International Silver Chippendale Silent butler Crumber Silver Plate
$8.95
Time Remaining: 3d 47m
Buy It Now for only: $28.00

Vintage silver plate silent butler billion jubilee NC Liff 1954 EBRodgers silver
Vintage silver plate silent butler billion jubilee NC Liff 1954 EBRodgers silver
$4.99
Time Remaining: 3d 49m

Vintage 1883 FB Rogers Silver Co Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Tray 386
Vintage 1883 FB Rogers Silver Co Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Tray 386
$24.95
Time Remaining: 3d 3h 31m
Buy It Now for only: $24.95

Vintage FB Rogers Silent Butler EUC Crumb Catcher 186 Silver
Vintage FB Rogers Silent Butler EUC Crumb Catcher 186 Silver
$9.99
Time Remaining: 3d 3h 59m

Silver Plate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Clam Shell Shaped Thumb Operated Hinge
Silver Plate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Clam Shell Shaped Thumb Operated Hinge
$10.99
Time Remaining: 3d 5h 1m

Vintage MAJOR AB ADVERSIS SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER W WOOD HANDLE 18 1900s
Vintage MAJOR AB ADVERSIS SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER W WOOD HANDLE 18 1900s
$3.95
Time Remaining: 3d 5h 22m

Rare Eugen Ferner 1962 M Silverplate Silent Butler
Rare Eugen Ferner 1962 M Silverplate Silent Butler
$12.99
Time Remaining: 3d 6h 3m
Buy It Now for only: $30.00

VINTAGE SHEFFIELD SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER CRUMB CATCHER EPC 269 Very cool
VINTAGE SHEFFIELD SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER CRUMB CATCHER EPC 269 Very cool
$7.99
Time Remaining: 3d 6h 37m

VINTAGE SILVER PLATE ON COPPER CRUMB CATCHER SILENT BUTLER
VINTAGE SILVER PLATE ON COPPER CRUMB CATCHER SILENT BUTLER
$6.99
Time Remaining: 3d 6h 45m

ANTIQUE SIGNED APOLLO SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER TRINKET BOX
ANTIQUE SIGNED APOLLO SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER TRINKET BOX
$14.99
Time Remaining: 3d 7h 3m

Sheffield Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Epc Wooden Handle
Sheffield Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Epc Wooden Handle
$19.99
Time Remaining: 3d 8h 22m

VINTAGE SILVER Co Peacock CRUMB SCRAPER  TRAY SILENT BUTLER QUADRUPLE PLATE
VINTAGE SILVER Co Peacock CRUMB SCRAPER TRAY SILENT BUTLER QUADRUPLE PLATE
$19.99
Time Remaining: 3d 8h 26m

Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Wood Handle Silver Plate Silent Butler
Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Wood Handle Silver Plate Silent Butler
$26.00
Time Remaining: 3d 8h 46m

HAND FORGED NASCO ITALY METAL SILENT BUTLER VINTAGE ca 30s 40s 50s
HAND FORGED NASCO ITALY METAL SILENT BUTLER VINTAGE ca 30s 40s 50s
$9.99
Time Remaining: 3d 9h 16m
Buy It Now for only: $9.99

STERLING SILVER SILENT BUTLER BY SANBORN 546 Grams Perfect Condition
STERLING SILVER SILENT BUTLER BY SANBORN 546 Grams Perfect Condition
$425.00
Time Remaining: 3d 9h 19m

Vtg Silent Butler CRUMB TRAY  BRUSH SET catcher silver reed barton antique
Vtg Silent Butler CRUMB TRAY BRUSH SET catcher silver reed barton antique
$39.99
Time Remaining: 3d 9h 59m

Vintage Silverplate SILENT BUTLER Horse Detail on Lid SHEFFIELD Silver Plate
Vintage Silverplate SILENT BUTLER Horse Detail on Lid SHEFFIELD Silver Plate
$17.99
Time Remaining: 3d 10h 33m

VTGMAJOR ADVERSIS BUTLER SILVER OVER COPPER SILENT BUTLER WITH A WOODEN HANDL
VTGMAJOR ADVERSIS BUTLER SILVER OVER COPPER SILENT BUTLER WITH A WOODEN HANDL
$35.00
Time Remaining: 3d 18h 26m

Vintage Silver Plate Footed Silent Butler with Wooden Handle  Lion Engraved
Vintage Silver Plate Footed Silent Butler with Wooden Handle Lion Engraved
$39.99
Time Remaining: 3d 18h 55m
Buy It Now for only: $39.99

Estate Sale Lot Vintage Salt  pepper shakers Silent Butler candle holders
Estate Sale Lot Vintage Salt pepper shakers Silent Butler candle holders
$9.99
Time Remaining: 3d 19h 17m

Vintage Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Friedman Co Silverplate NY 1908 1960
Vintage Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Friedman Co Silverplate NY 1908 1960
$29.99
Time Remaining: 3d 19h 44m
Buy It Now for only: $29.99

F B Rogers Silver Co Silent Butler 386 with Feet  Wood Handle
F B Rogers Silver Co Silent Butler 386 with Feet Wood Handle
$10.95
Time Remaining: 3d 21h 36m

Sheffield Silverplate E P C Silent Butler witn Wood Handle Horse Design
Sheffield Silverplate E P C Silent Butler witn Wood Handle Horse Design
$14.95
Time Remaining: 3d 22h 27m

Beautiful Silverplate Silent Butler by Guildcraft Silversmiths
Beautiful Silverplate Silent Butler by Guildcraft Silversmiths
$7.99
Time Remaining: 3d 22h 44m
Buy It Now for only: $7.99

Antique Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Pan Tray English Turned Wood Handle
Antique Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Pan Tray English Turned Wood Handle
$3.00
Time Remaining: 3d 23h 32m
Buy It Now for only: $3.00

Antique Vintage Silver Wilcox Silent Butler
Antique Vintage Silver Wilcox Silent Butler
$9.95
Time Remaining: 4d 1h 7m

ANTIQUE SILENT BUTLER SILVER PLATED SHEFFIELD EPC 269 EXCELLENT
ANTIQUE SILENT BUTLER SILVER PLATED SHEFFIELD EPC 269 EXCELLENT
$14.25
Time Remaining: 4d 1h 19m

Vintage Sheffield Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher
Vintage Sheffield Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher
$20.87
Time Remaining: 4d 1h 32m
Buy It Now for only: $20.87

VTG FB Roger Silverplate Copper Silent Butler pattern  188 unicorn 1883
VTG FB Roger Silverplate Copper Silent Butler pattern 188 unicorn 1883
$9.99
Time Remaining: 4d 3h 22m
Buy It Now for only: $9.99

CANTERBURY ARTS VINTAGE SILENT BUTLER ASH TRAY
CANTERBURY ARTS VINTAGE SILENT BUTLER ASH TRAY
$15.00
Time Remaining: 4d 3h 22m
Buy It Now for only: $15.00

Vintage FB Rogers Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Ash Catcher Major AB Adversis
Vintage FB Rogers Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Ash Catcher Major AB Adversis
$20.00
Time Remaining: 4d 6h 40m
Buy It Now for only: $26.00

Vintage FB Rogers Silent Butler EUC Crumb Catcher 186 Silver
Vintage FB Rogers Silent Butler EUC Crumb Catcher 186 Silver
$28.99
Time Remaining: 4d 8h 35m
Buy It Now for only: $45.00

Vintage EPC Silent Butler by Poole Silver Company 75 Lion Crest Lid
Vintage EPC Silent Butler by Poole Silver Company 75 Lion Crest Lid
$34.99
Time Remaining: 4d 9h 13m
Buy It Now for only: $34.99

ANTIQUE 1900S SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER TO EMPTY ASHTRAYS  CRUMB CATCHER
ANTIQUE 1900S SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER TO EMPTY ASHTRAYS CRUMB CATCHER
$31.44
Time Remaining: 4d 11h 18m
Buy It Now for only: $31.44

1920s SILVERPLATE 2 PIECE SILENT BUTLER OR CRUMBER SET by MANNING BOWMAN and CO
1920s SILVERPLATE 2 PIECE SILENT BUTLER OR CRUMBER SET by MANNING BOWMAN and CO
$45.00
Time Remaining: 4d 12h 35m


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,