Silent Butler

March 6, 2010 10:42 am | silver antiques

How close is Phantom of the Opera (2004) musical to the original 1925 version?

The question is self explanatory, but since I only saw parts and not all of the 1925 version, I was wondering how well it adapts the original story.
I'm a great fan of musicals, Gerard Butler, but also of the silent film era and Lon Chaney. Man was a genius when it came to acting and make up. So I wonder, how close are these two stories linked?
And also, in your personal opinion, which do you find better? ( I know it's different genres, but u have a preference!! )

About as close as the North Pole is to the South Pole. In that they both are at ends of the earth, have sub-zero temperatures, darkness for months on end, etc. But otherwise, thaaaaaat far apart.

Vintage silver silent butler rose design
Vintage silver silent butler rose design
$25.00
Time Remaining: 5h 36m
Buy It Now for only: $25.00

Antique Ashtray bowl silver plate Silent Butler Coat of arms Hallmark 6302
Antique Ashtray bowl silver plate Silent Butler Coat of arms Hallmark 6302
$149.99
Time Remaining: 6h 18m
Buy It Now for only: $149.99

Vintage silver silent butler fish motif
Vintage silver silent butler fish motif
$28.00
Time Remaining: 7h 37m
Buy It Now for only: $28.00

Vintage Silverplate Victorian Pattern Silent Butler or Crumb Catcher No Marks
Vintage Silverplate Victorian Pattern Silent Butler or Crumb Catcher No Marks
$75.00
Time Remaining: 9h 6m
Buy It Now for only: $97.50

Silverplate F B Rogers Silver Co Silent Butler 386 with Feet
Silverplate F B Rogers Silver Co Silent Butler 386 with Feet
$7.00
Time Remaining: 9h 33m

Rare Antique Vintage Silver Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Hallmark French
Rare Antique Vintage Silver Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Hallmark French
$1.69 (3 Bids)
Time Remaining: 10h 39m

Vintage Silver Silent Butler Crumb Ash Tray With Marking On Top
Vintage Silver Silent Butler Crumb Ash Tray With Marking On Top
$19.99
Time Remaining: 12h 11m

VINTAGE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER DUST PAN CRUMB TRAY SHIPS FEATHER DESIGN JAPAN
VINTAGE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER DUST PAN CRUMB TRAY SHIPS FEATHER DESIGN JAPAN
$6.50
Time Remaining: 14h 6m
Buy It Now for only: $6.50

Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Co Marked
Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Co Marked
$10.99
Time Remaining: 14h 26m

Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Engraved Etched Lions Crowns ESSAY EFCN Design
Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Engraved Etched Lions Crowns ESSAY EFCN Design
$18.95
Time Remaining: 14h 27m

Antique Sheffield Silverplate Crumb Catcher Silent Butler FB Rogers ashtray
Antique Sheffield Silverplate Crumb Catcher Silent Butler FB Rogers ashtray
$10.00
Time Remaining: 14h 30m

Antique Napier Silverplate Crumb Catcher Silent Butler Ashtray
Antique Napier Silverplate Crumb Catcher Silent Butler Ashtray
$20.00
Time Remaining: 14h 30m

ANTIQUE SHEFFIELD SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER
ANTIQUE SHEFFIELD SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER
$15.00
Time Remaining: 15h 14m

VINTAGE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER MAKER UNKNOWN
VINTAGE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER MAKER UNKNOWN
$18.99
Time Remaining: 15h 24m
Buy It Now for only: $24.99

Silent Butler 1900s Sheffield Ash Crumb Catcher or Silent Butler EPC 270
Silent Butler 1900s Sheffield Ash Crumb Catcher or Silent Butler EPC 270
$249.00
Time Remaining: 15h 25m
Buy It Now for only: $249.00

Baroque by Wallace 265 Silverplate Silent Butler Ash Tray Dish Vintage
Baroque by Wallace 265 Silverplate Silent Butler Ash Tray Dish Vintage
$24.99
Time Remaining: 16h 5m

Antique Silverplate Silent Butler with Wood Handle
Antique Silverplate Silent Butler with Wood Handle
$2.99
Time Remaining: 18h 14m

Antique Keystoneware Silverplated Silent Butler Crumb Catcher
Antique Keystoneware Silverplated Silent Butler Crumb Catcher
$24.99
Time Remaining: 19h 10m
Buy It Now for only: $24.99

Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Made in USA
Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Made in USA
$19.99
Time Remaining: 1d 2h 4m
Buy It Now for only: $19.99

Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Co Made in USA Marked
Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Co Made in USA Marked
$39.99
Time Remaining: 1d 5h 18m

Wallace silver silent butler 908
Wallace silver silent butler 908
$55.00
Time Remaining: 1d 6h 21m
Buy It Now for only: $55.00

Poole EPC Silverplate Silent Butler Unicorns Crumb Catcher Heavily Tarnished
Poole EPC Silverplate Silent Butler Unicorns Crumb Catcher Heavily Tarnished
$14.95
Time Remaining: 1d 6h 43m

WM ROGERS  SON VICTORIAN ROSE ASH CRUMB CATCHER SILENT BUTLER
WM ROGERS SON VICTORIAN ROSE ASH CRUMB CATCHER SILENT BUTLER
$10.99
Time Remaining: 1d 7h 41m

RARE ANTIQUE Hand Wrought Silent Butler Crumb Pan w Lid Floral
RARE ANTIQUE Hand Wrought Silent Butler Crumb Pan w Lid Floral
$16.99
Time Remaining: 1d 8h 39m
Buy It Now for only: $24.00

ANTIQUE SILENT BUTLER SILVERPLATE WOOD HANDLE LION CREST SITTING UP
ANTIQUE SILENT BUTLER SILVERPLATE WOOD HANDLE LION CREST SITTING UP
$12.99
Time Remaining: 1d 8h 45m

Vintage SILENT BUTLER Wm Rogers Silverplate Shell Shape with Claw Feet
Vintage SILENT BUTLER Wm Rogers Silverplate Shell Shape with Claw Feet
$8.48
Time Remaining: 1d 9h 26m

Silver Plate Wood Handle Oval Silent Butler Engraved Lion Marked Regency 15
Silver Plate Wood Handle Oval Silent Butler Engraved Lion Marked Regency 15
$8.00
Time Remaining: 1d 9h 27m

Vintage SILVER PLATED Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Pan By SHEFFIELD SILVER CO
Vintage SILVER PLATED Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Pan By SHEFFIELD SILVER CO
$15.00
Time Remaining: 1d 9h 33m
Buy It Now for only: $15.00

VTG Manning Bowman CoSilver Plated Silent Butler Plate Crumb Tray
VTG Manning Bowman CoSilver Plated Silent Butler Plate Crumb Tray
$18.99
Time Remaining: 1d 11h 35m
Buy It Now for only: $18.99

Sanborns Mexico Sterling Silver Silent Butler
Sanborns Mexico Sterling Silver Silent Butler
$275.00
Time Remaining: 1d 11h 51m
Buy It Now for only: $357.50

Vintage FB Rogers Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Ash Catcher Major AB Adversis
Vintage FB Rogers Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Ash Catcher Major AB Adversis
$12.00
Time Remaining: 1d 13h 11m
Buy It Now for only: $16.00

Friedmans Silent Butler Crumb Tray SliverPlate
Friedmans Silent Butler Crumb Tray SliverPlate
$6.00
Time Remaining: 1d 13h 39m

Vtg Sheffield Silverplate Crumb Catcher Silent Butler Pan Wood Handle No 268
Vtg Sheffield Silverplate Crumb Catcher Silent Butler Pan Wood Handle No 268
$29.95
Time Remaining: 1d 15h 37m

Vintage Sheffield Silver Company Silent Butler Crumb Catcher 1908
Vintage Sheffield Silver Company Silent Butler Crumb Catcher 1908
$16.95
Time Remaining: 1d 16h 9m
Buy It Now for only: $16.95

Vtg Silent Butler Ashtray Great Condition
Vtg Silent Butler Ashtray Great Condition
$35.00
Time Remaining: 1d 16h 23m

Antique Silent Butler Silver Plated with bakelite thumb knob
Antique Silent Butler Silver Plated with bakelite thumb knob
$23.00
Time Remaining: 1d 17h 17m
Buy It Now for only: $30.00

Lovely Vintage Sterling Silver Silent Butler Mexico City c1940s
Lovely Vintage Sterling Silver Silent Butler Mexico City c1940s
$250.24
Time Remaining: 1d 17h 45m
Buy It Now for only: $250.24

Vintage Rectangular SILENT BUTLER by Irvin Ware Co
Vintage Rectangular SILENT BUTLER by Irvin Ware Co
$4.99
Time Remaining: 1d 18h 27m

MIXED LOT SILVER PLATE BREAD TRAY TRIVET SILENT BUTLER
MIXED LOT SILVER PLATE BREAD TRAY TRIVET SILENT BUTLER
$18.00
Time Remaining: 1d 19h 27m

Vintage EPC Poole Silver Co Silver Plated Silent Butler Lion Insignia 3810
Vintage EPC Poole Silver Co Silver Plated Silent Butler Lion Insignia 3810
$31.99
Time Remaining: 1d 19h 48m
Buy It Now for only: $41.99

Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Silverplate Silent Butler Stallion on Top Hinged
Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Silverplate Silent Butler Stallion on Top Hinged
$10.67
Time Remaining: 1d 20h 32m

Union Air 205 Silver Plate Silent Butler
Union Air 205 Silver Plate Silent Butler
$29.99
Time Remaining: 2d 35m

Vintage Silver Plate Footed Silent Butler with Wooden Handle  Lion Engraved
Vintage Silver Plate Footed Silent Butler with Wooden Handle Lion Engraved
$39.99
Time Remaining: 2d 5h 28m
Buy It Now for only: $39.99

Vintage Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Friedman Co Silverplate NY 1908 1960
Vintage Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Friedman Co Silverplate NY 1908 1960
$29.99
Time Remaining: 2d 6h 17m
Buy It Now for only: $29.99

Sheridan Silverplated Silent Butler Pan with Removable Wooden Handle from 1978
Sheridan Silverplated Silent Butler Pan with Removable Wooden Handle from 1978
$18.00
Time Remaining: 2d 6h 38m
Buy It Now for only: $18.00

Vintage Silent Butler Bristol Silver EPCA 102 Ash Crumb Tray VGUC
Vintage Silent Butler Bristol Silver EPCA 102 Ash Crumb Tray VGUC
$9.31
Time Remaining: 2d 8h 18m
Buy It Now for only: $9.31

ANTIQUE 50S POOLE SILVER COSILENT BUTLER SILVER PLATED GOOD CONDITION USED
ANTIQUE 50S POOLE SILVER COSILENT BUTLER SILVER PLATED GOOD CONDITION USED
$24.99
Time Remaining: 2d 9h 43m

OLD SHEFFIELD SILVER CO SILENT BUTLER CRUMB TRAY 268 UNICORN DESIGN
OLD SHEFFIELD SILVER CO SILENT BUTLER CRUMB TRAY 268 UNICORN DESIGN
$35.00
Time Remaining: 2d 10h 2m
Buy It Now for only: $35.00

Vintage Oneida LTD Silver Plated 3 Footed Silent Butler Crest Inscribed
Vintage Oneida LTD Silver Plated 3 Footed Silent Butler Crest Inscribed
$19.99
Time Remaining: 2d 11h 39m
Buy It Now for only: $19.99

1920s SILVERPLATE 2 PIECE SILENT BUTLER OR CRUMBER SET by MANNING BOWMAN and CO
1920s SILVERPLATE 2 PIECE SILENT BUTLER OR CRUMBER SET by MANNING BOWMAN and CO
$45.00
Time Remaining: 2d 12h 6m

SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER w WOOD HANDLE
SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER w WOOD HANDLE
$10.00
Time Remaining: 2d 12h 25m

Vintage FB ROGERS SILVER CO 386 Silent Butler or Crumb Tray
Vintage FB ROGERS SILVER CO 386 Silent Butler or Crumb Tray
$7.25
Time Remaining: 2d 13h 41m

CANTERBURY ARTS VINTAGE SILENT BUTLER ASH TRAY
CANTERBURY ARTS VINTAGE SILENT BUTLER ASH TRAY
$15.00
Time Remaining: 2d 13h 55m
Buy It Now for only: $15.00

VINTAGE SILVER PLATED Silent Butler Crumb CatcherrPoole Silver Co
VINTAGE SILVER PLATED Silent Butler Crumb CatcherrPoole Silver Co
$11.99
Time Remaining: 2d 13h 56m

Vintage Sheffield Silver Silent Butler Horse
Vintage Sheffield Silver Silent Butler Horse
$13.00
Time Remaining: 2d 16h 27m
Buy It Now for only: $17.00

Vintage Silent Butler Unmarked Silver Plate Glass Liner Crumb or Ash Collector
Vintage Silent Butler Unmarked Silver Plate Glass Liner Crumb or Ash Collector
$7.99
Time Remaining: 2d 16h 44m

Silent Butler Silver over Copper Crumb Catcher Wood Handle
Silent Butler Silver over Copper Crumb Catcher Wood Handle
$25.00
Time Remaining: 2d 17h 45m

Vintage Sheffield Silverplated Silent Butler Crumb Catcher EPC 269 Wood Handle
Vintage Sheffield Silverplated Silent Butler Crumb Catcher EPC 269 Wood Handle
$15.99
Time Remaining: 2d 18h 33m
Buy It Now for only: $22.99

Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler
Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler
$9.99
Time Remaining: 2d 19h 5m

ANTIQUE SHEFFIELD SILVER CO SILENT BUTLER CRUMB TRAY 268 UNICORN DESIGN
ANTIQUE SHEFFIELD SILVER CO SILENT BUTLER CRUMB TRAY 268 UNICORN DESIGN
$6.99
Time Remaining: 2d 19h 8m

Vtg Silent Butler CRUMB TRAY  BRUSH SET catcher silver reed barton antique
Vtg Silent Butler CRUMB TRAY BRUSH SET catcher silver reed barton antique
$35.99
Time Remaining: 2d 19h 38m

SILENT BUTLER Crumb Catcher SILVERPLATE WOOD HANDLE Vintage VGT9
SILENT BUTLER Crumb Catcher SILVERPLATE WOOD HANDLE Vintage VGT9
$24.99
Time Remaining: 3d 4h 21m

Near Antique Silent Butler  Brush 40 Silver Unique
Near Antique Silent Butler Brush 40 Silver Unique
$160.00
Time Remaining: 3d 4h 33m
Buy It Now for only: $220.00

SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER BARBER BRO BRILLIANT SHINE
SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER BARBER BRO BRILLIANT SHINE
$8.99
Time Remaining: 3d 5h 5m

ANTIQUE SHEFFIELD SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER WOOD HANDLE
ANTIQUE SHEFFIELD SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER WOOD HANDLE
$6.00
Time Remaining: 3d 5h 54m

Antique Vintage Silver Wilcox Silent Butler
Antique Vintage Silver Wilcox Silent Butler
$19.95
Time Remaining: 3d 8h 50m
Buy It Now for only: $19.95

Vintage Crown 925 Silver plate Silent Butler Crumb Duster Tray D
Vintage Crown 925 Silver plate Silent Butler Crumb Duster Tray D
$24.99
Time Remaining: 3d 9h 16m

Vintage Silver silent butler crumber ash catcher
Vintage Silver silent butler crumber ash catcher
$19.99
Time Remaining: 3d 10h 45m
Buy It Now for only: $19.99

Antique Hannay Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Tray Dust Pan Bone Handle
Antique Hannay Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Tray Dust Pan Bone Handle
$45.99
Time Remaining: 3d 10h 53m
Buy It Now for only: $85.00

Vintage Modern Silver Mfg Co Silverplated Silent Butler1950 1958Wood Handle
Vintage Modern Silver Mfg Co Silverplated Silent Butler1950 1958Wood Handle
$14.99
Time Remaining: 3d 11h 22m
Buy It Now for only: $14.99

Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Lion Heraldic En Race Affle W Wooden Handle
Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Lion Heraldic En Race Affle W Wooden Handle
$5.50
Time Remaining: 3d 14h 1m

FB Rogers Silver plated Silent Butler
FB Rogers Silver plated Silent Butler
$8.00
Time Remaining: 3d 14h 26m
Buy It Now for only: $8.00

ANTIQUE F B ROGERS SILVER PLATE WOODEN HANDLE 4 LEGS STANDING SILENT BUTLER
ANTIQUE F B ROGERS SILVER PLATE WOODEN HANDLE 4 LEGS STANDING SILENT BUTLER
$26.99
Time Remaining: 3d 14h 49m
Buy It Now for only: $59.99

Vintage FB Roger Silver Co 1883 Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Tray Collector
Vintage FB Roger Silver Co 1883 Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Tray Collector
$5.00
Time Remaining: 3d 18h 51m
Buy It Now for only: $5.00

GREAT VINTAGE GORHAM SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER CRUMB REMOVER DUST PAN
GREAT VINTAGE GORHAM SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER CRUMB REMOVER DUST PAN
$19.99
Time Remaining: 3d 19h 1m

Vintage Silverplate Lot Silent Butler Lided Wooden Handle
Vintage Silverplate Lot Silent Butler Lided Wooden Handle
$125.95
Time Remaining: 3d 19h 49m
Buy It Now for only: $125.95

Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Co Made in USA Marked
Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Co Made in USA Marked
$37.75
Time Remaining: 3d 21h 42m
Buy It Now for only: $37.75

Wallace Grande Baroque Silverplate Silent Butler Ash Tray Dish Vintage w patina
Wallace Grande Baroque Silverplate Silent Butler Ash Tray Dish Vintage w patina
$42.00
Time Remaining: 4d 52m
Buy It Now for only: $42.00

Vintage Silver Plated Silent Butler Ash Tray
Vintage Silver Plated Silent Butler Ash Tray
$22.99
Time Remaining: 4d 2h 49m

Silent Butler Grammes Beautiful floral lid
Silent Butler Grammes Beautiful floral lid
$24.99
Time Remaining: 4d 5h 45m
Buy It Now for only: $45.00

BRASS Vintage Clam Shell lidded Silent butler LIGHTER  TWO SMALL ASHTRAYS
BRASS Vintage Clam Shell lidded Silent butler LIGHTER TWO SMALL ASHTRAYS
$38.88
Time Remaining: 4d 7h 18m

Vintage 1883 F B Rogers Silver Co Silent Butler Butter dish Silver Plate 88
Vintage 1883 F B Rogers Silver Co Silent Butler Butter dish Silver Plate 88
$12.99
Time Remaining: 4d 8h 30m


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,