Silent Butler

March 6, 2010 10:42 am | silver antiques

How close is Phantom of the Opera (2004) musical to the original 1925 version?

The question is self explanatory, but since I only saw parts and not all of the 1925 version, I was wondering how well it adapts the original story.
I'm a great fan of musicals, Gerard Butler, but also of the silent film era and Lon Chaney. Man was a genius when it came to acting and make up. So I wonder, how close are these two stories linked?
And also, in your personal opinion, which do you find better? ( I know it's different genres, but u have a preference!! )

About as close as the North Pole is to the South Pole. In that they both are at ends of the earth, have sub-zero temperatures, darkness for months on end, etc. But otherwise, thaaaaaat far apart.

VTGMAJOR AB ADVERSIS BUTLER SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER WITH A WOODEN HANDLE
VTGMAJOR AB ADVERSIS BUTLER SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER WITH A WOODEN HANDLE
$19.99
Time Remaining: 1h 17m

SILENT BUTLER SILVERPLATE FRIEDMAN SILVER
SILENT BUTLER SILVERPLATE FRIEDMAN SILVER
$10.99
Time Remaining: 2h 14m
Buy It Now for only: $10.99

VINTAGE SILVER SILENT BUTLER HAND HELD ASH TRAY HINDGED LID 10 1 2 LENGTH
VINTAGE SILVER SILENT BUTLER HAND HELD ASH TRAY HINDGED LID 10 1 2 LENGTH
$49.00
Time Remaining: 3h 3m
Buy It Now for only: $49.00

Vintage MAJOR AB ADVERSIS SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER W WOOD HANDLE
Vintage MAJOR AB ADVERSIS SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER W WOOD HANDLE
$6.00
Time Remaining: 3h 29m
Buy It Now for only: $6.00

Vintage 1940s Oneida Silversmith Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Tray
Vintage 1940s Oneida Silversmith Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Tray
$14.99
Time Remaining: 3h 52m

Vtg Sheffield Silverplate Crumb Catcher Silent Butler Pan Wood Handle No 268
Vtg Sheffield Silverplate Crumb Catcher Silent Butler Pan Wood Handle No 268
$26.95
Time Remaining: 3h 53m
Buy It Now for only: $26.95

VTG Silver Plate on Copper Silent Butler Ashtray EPC with Waterhorse Hippocamp
VTG Silver Plate on Copper Silent Butler Ashtray EPC with Waterhorse Hippocamp
$35.05
Time Remaining: 4h 53m
Buy It Now for only: $35.05

Vintage Crown 925 Silver plate Silent Butler Crumb Duster Tray D
Vintage Crown 925 Silver plate Silent Butler Crumb Duster Tray D
$24.99
Time Remaining: 5h 38m
Buy It Now for only: $24.99

Sheffield Silver Co Silver Plated Silent Butler with Brush
Sheffield Silver Co Silver Plated Silent Butler with Brush
$26.45
Time Remaining: 6h 51m

VINTAGE SILVERPLATED SILENT BUTLER HALMARK ILLEGIBLENO RESERVE
VINTAGE SILVERPLATED SILENT BUTLER HALMARK ILLEGIBLENO RESERVE
$9.90
Time Remaining: 9h 3m
Buy It Now for only: $9.90

VINTAGE F B ROGERS SILVER CO SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER 386 IN BOX Footed
VINTAGE F B ROGERS SILVER CO SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER 386 IN BOX Footed
$13.75
Time Remaining: 9h 9m

SHEFFIELD SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER ASHTRAY CRUMB CATCHER
SHEFFIELD SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER ASHTRAY CRUMB CATCHER
$15.00
Time Remaining: 10h 28m

Silent butler crumb tray with rampant stallion design
Silent butler crumb tray with rampant stallion design
$50.00
Time Remaining: 10h 34m

Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Engraved Etched Lions Crowns ESSAY EFCN Design
Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Engraved Etched Lions Crowns ESSAY EFCN Design
$14.95
Time Remaining: 10h 48m

Antique Silver Plate Ornate Silent Butler Crumb Tray And Crescent Brush Japan
Antique Silver Plate Ornate Silent Butler Crumb Tray And Crescent Brush Japan
$290.00
Time Remaining: 11h 18m
Buy It Now for only: $290.00

Vintage FB Rogers Silver Co Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher
Vintage FB Rogers Silver Co Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher
$4.99
Time Remaining: 12h 4m

VINTAGE 1920s ART DECO TABLE CRUMB SWEEPER ORNATE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER
VINTAGE 1920s ART DECO TABLE CRUMB SWEEPER ORNATE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER
$19.95
Time Remaining: 14h 5m
Buy It Now for only: $19.95

Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Silver Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Home Garden
Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Silver Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Home Garden
$35.00
Time Remaining: 14h 18m
Buy It Now for only: $35.00

VINTAGE SILVER PLATED Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Poole Silver Co 8 1 2 long
VINTAGE SILVER PLATED Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Poole Silver Co 8 1 2 long
$10.99
Time Remaining: 14h 25m

ANTIQUE SHEFFIELD SILVERPLATED SILENT BUTLER CRUMB CATCHER W WOOD HANDLE
ANTIQUE SHEFFIELD SILVERPLATED SILENT BUTLER CRUMB CATCHER W WOOD HANDLE
$9.99
Time Remaining: 16h 1m
Buy It Now for only: $9.99

VINTAGE SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER ASHTRAY W LID  HANDLECRUMB CATCHER
VINTAGE SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER ASHTRAY W LID HANDLECRUMB CATCHER
$24.99
Time Remaining: 1d 3h 29m
Buy It Now for only: $24.99

FB Rogers Silver Plate Round Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Ash Can Antique
FB Rogers Silver Plate Round Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Ash Can Antique
$14.99
Time Remaining: 1d 3h 35m
Buy It Now for only: $14.99

Crescent Silverware Mfg Co Silent Butler Crumb Ash Catcher Silver Plate Antique
Crescent Silverware Mfg Co Silent Butler Crumb Ash Catcher Silver Plate Antique
$14.99
Time Remaining: 1d 3h 45m
Buy It Now for only: $14.99

SHEFFIELD SILVER CO SILENT BUTLER CRUMB TRAY
SHEFFIELD SILVER CO SILENT BUTLER CRUMB TRAY
$20.00
Time Remaining: 1d 7h 22m

FB Rogers Silent Butler Silverplate
FB Rogers Silent Butler Silverplate
$15.00
Time Remaining: 1d 7h 38m
Buy It Now for only: $15.00

VINTAGE HAMMERED ALUMINUM SILENT BUTLER BY EVERLAST
VINTAGE HAMMERED ALUMINUM SILENT BUTLER BY EVERLAST
$9.50
Time Remaining: 1d 9h 48m
Buy It Now for only: $9.50

Wallace Baroque Silverplate Silent Butler Ash Tray Dish Vintage
Wallace Baroque Silverplate Silent Butler Ash Tray Dish Vintage
$45.99
Time Remaining: 1d 10h 6m
Buy It Now for only: $45.99

Vintage English Silver Plate Silent Butler Wood Handle Silver Claw Feet Bottom
Vintage English Silver Plate Silent Butler Wood Handle Silver Claw Feet Bottom
$6.99
Time Remaining: 1d 11h 27m

Embossed Griffith on Gorham Silver Plate Silent Butler with Wood Handle YC135
Embossed Griffith on Gorham Silver Plate Silent Butler with Wood Handle YC135
$14.99
Time Remaining: 1d 12h 48m
Buy It Now for only: $14.99

Vintage Japan Silver Metal Dust Pan Silent Butler Victorian Dust Pan LQQK
Vintage Japan Silver Metal Dust Pan Silent Butler Victorian Dust Pan LQQK
$29.99
Time Remaining: 1d 14h 57m
Buy It Now for only: $29.99

Vintage Derby Silverplate Silent Butler Quadruple Silver Plate
Vintage Derby Silverplate Silent Butler Quadruple Silver Plate
$12.99
Time Remaining: 1d 15h 18m

VINTAGE ROGERS 1883 SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER MAJOR AD ADVERSIS
VINTAGE ROGERS 1883 SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER MAJOR AD ADVERSIS
$14.23
Time Remaining: 1d 16h 25m
Buy It Now for only: $14.23

c1906 SB STERLING Silver SAART BROTHERS Clothes BRUSH  SHOE HORN Silent Butler
c1906 SB STERLING Silver SAART BROTHERS Clothes BRUSH SHOE HORN Silent Butler
$40.00
Time Remaining: 1d 16h 51m
Buy It Now for only: $40.00

Vintage 1883 F B Rodgers Silver Co Silent Butler Crumb Tray 386
Vintage 1883 F B Rodgers Silver Co Silent Butler Crumb Tray 386
$9.99
Time Remaining: 2d 3h 24m
Buy It Now for only: $25.99

Vintage F B Rogers Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Post 1940
Vintage F B Rogers Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Post 1940
$2.99
Time Remaining: 2d 3h 34m

Engraved Rampant Lion Silent Butler Silver Plate Crest Silverplate
Engraved Rampant Lion Silent Butler Silver Plate Crest Silverplate
$33.30
Time Remaining: 2d 5h 33m
Buy It Now for only: $33.30

Vintage Sheffield Silverplate Silent Butler Cumbpan
Vintage Sheffield Silverplate Silent Butler Cumbpan
$49.99
Time Remaining: 2d 5h 42m
Buy It Now for only: $49.99

Vintage silver plate silent butler billion jubilee NC Liff 1954 EBRodgers silver
Vintage silver plate silent butler billion jubilee NC Liff 1954 EBRodgers silver
$4.99
Time Remaining: 2d 5h 45m

Vintage Sheffield Silver Plate on Copper Silent Butler crumb tray
Vintage Sheffield Silver Plate on Copper Silent Butler crumb tray
$9.99
Time Remaining: 2d 6h 41m

HAND FORGED NASCO ITALY METAL SILENT BUTLER VINTAGE ca 30s 40s 50s
HAND FORGED NASCO ITALY METAL SILENT BUTLER VINTAGE ca 30s 40s 50s
$6.00
Time Remaining: 2d 7h 2m
Buy It Now for only: $6.00

ANTIQUE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER CRUMB TRAY GRIFFONS OLD VINTAGE ITALY QUALITY
ANTIQUE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER CRUMB TRAY GRIFFONS OLD VINTAGE ITALY QUALITY
$55.96
Time Remaining: 2d 8h 25m
Buy It Now for only: $55.96

Silent Butler Silver Plated Crumb Catcher
Silent Butler Silver Plated Crumb Catcher
$25.00
Time Remaining: 2d 9h 48m
Buy It Now for only: $25.00

antique Vintage English silent butler with lid silver plate wood handle
antique Vintage English silent butler with lid silver plate wood handle
$22.00
Time Remaining: 2d 11h

Sheffield Silverplate Ball  Claw Footed Silent Butler EPC 300 Wood Handle
Sheffield Silverplate Ball Claw Footed Silent Butler EPC 300 Wood Handle
$39.99
Time Remaining: 2d 11h 16m
Buy It Now for only: $39.99

Sheffield Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb or Ash Catcher Etched Horse Exc Cond
Sheffield Silverplate Silent Butler Crumb or Ash Catcher Etched Horse Exc Cond
$9.99
Time Remaining: 2d 11h 24m

Wallace Grande Baroque Silverplate Silent Butler Ash Tray Dish Vintage
Wallace Grande Baroque Silverplate Silent Butler Ash Tray Dish Vintage
$65.00
Time Remaining: 2d 14h 50m
Buy It Now for only: $65.00

Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Co Marked
Vintage Silverplate Silent Butler Sheffield Silver Co Marked
$9.99
Time Remaining: 2d 17h 12m

Vintage SIlver Plate Chippendale Silent Butler Crumb or Ash Tray with Lid
Vintage SIlver Plate Chippendale Silent Butler Crumb or Ash Tray with Lid
$9.99
Time Remaining: 2d 20h 41m

VINTAGE ANTIQUE SILVER ON COPPER ESSAYERON SILENT BUTLER OR CROMB CATCHER
VINTAGE ANTIQUE SILVER ON COPPER ESSAYERON SILENT BUTLER OR CROMB CATCHER
$24.95
Time Remaining: 3d 4h 15m
Buy It Now for only: $24.95

Two Vintage Crumber Silent Butler Silverplated  Brass Tone Israel Oppenheim EPC
Two Vintage Crumber Silent Butler Silverplated Brass Tone Israel Oppenheim EPC
$65.00
Time Remaining: 3d 6h 43m
Buy It Now for only: $65.00

Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Silverplate Silent Butler Ash Tray w Horse Crest
Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Silverplate Silent Butler Ash Tray w Horse Crest
$26.95
Time Remaining: 3d 7h 27m
Buy It Now for only: $26.95

Vtg Sheffield Silver Co Wood Handle Plate Silent Butler Crumb Crumber Dish EPC
Vtg Sheffield Silver Co Wood Handle Plate Silent Butler Crumb Crumber Dish EPC
$24.94
Time Remaining: 3d 12h 25m
Buy It Now for only: $24.94

ANTIQUE 1950S CROSBY SILVER ON COPPER SILENT BUTLER
ANTIQUE 1950S CROSBY SILVER ON COPPER SILENT BUTLER
$29.95
Time Remaining: 3d 12h 54m
Buy It Now for only: $29.95

Vintage Silverplate Sheffield Silent Butler w Brush 301 Engraved Horse Design
Vintage Silverplate Sheffield Silent Butler w Brush 301 Engraved Horse Design
$12.99
Time Remaining: 3d 14h 13m

WMA Rogers Oneida Silver Smith Round Silent Butler Ash Crumb Silver Plate Vintag
WMA Rogers Oneida Silver Smith Round Silent Butler Ash Crumb Silver Plate Vintag
$16.99
Time Remaining: 4d 2h 30m
Buy It Now for only: $24.00

Silver on Copper Silent Butler with wooden handle from the 1950s
Silver on Copper Silent Butler with wooden handle from the 1950s
$10.00
Time Remaining: 4d 2h 37m
Buy It Now for only: $25.00

VNTG SHEFFIELD SILVERPLATED SILENT BUTLERNO RESERVE
VNTG SHEFFIELD SILVERPLATED SILENT BUTLERNO RESERVE
$9.90
Time Remaining: 4d 3h 25m
Buy It Now for only: $9.90

Vintage Silver Plated Silent Butler Wood Handle weighs over a lb Has Markings
Vintage Silver Plated Silent Butler Wood Handle weighs over a lb Has Markings
$8.00
Time Remaining: 4d 3h 49m
Buy It Now for only: $8.00

SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER MADE BY UNION AIR USA SILVER PLATED 205
SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER MADE BY UNION AIR USA SILVER PLATED 205
$29.99
Time Remaining: 4d 6h 2m
Buy It Now for only: $29.99

Silent Butler with Lion Insignia Academy Silver on Copper 75 x 55 w handle
Silent Butler with Lion Insignia Academy Silver on Copper 75 x 55 w handle
$11.99
Time Remaining: 4d 6h 13m

Silverplate Ash Crumb Pan Silent Butler
Silverplate Ash Crumb Pan Silent Butler
$30.00
Time Remaining: 4d 7h 8m

VINTAGE SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER CRUMB CATCHER MADE IN NEW BERYPORT
VINTAGE SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER CRUMB CATCHER MADE IN NEW BERYPORT
$14.99
Time Remaining: 4d 7h 59m

Vintage Silverplated Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Wooden Handle Crescent 34 N
Vintage Silverplated Silent Butler Crumb Catcher Wooden Handle Crescent 34 N
$19.50
Time Remaining: 4d 8h 35m

VINTAGE SILENT BUTLER
VINTAGE SILENT BUTLER
$15.00
Time Remaining: 4d 9h 14m
Buy It Now for only: $20.00

Silver Plate Lot Reed  Barton 143 Oneida Silent Butler  More With Patina
Silver Plate Lot Reed Barton 143 Oneida Silent Butler More With Patina
$8.99
Time Remaining: 4d 9h 45m

Vintage Silver Plate Silent Butler With Wood Handle
Vintage Silver Plate Silent Butler With Wood Handle
$11.99
Time Remaining: 4d 10h 37m

VINTAGE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER MAKER UNKNOWN
VINTAGE SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER MAKER UNKNOWN
$13.99
Time Remaining: 4d 11h 4m
Buy It Now for only: $18.99

VINTAGE SHEFFIELD SILVER COMPANY SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER
VINTAGE SHEFFIELD SILVER COMPANY SILVER PLATED SILENT BUTLER
$10.00
Time Remaining: 4d 11h 10m

VTG FBRogers MAJOR AB ADVERSIS Silverplated Silent Butler RARE
VTG FBRogers MAJOR AB ADVERSIS Silverplated Silent Butler RARE
$10.95
Time Remaining: 4d 11h 26m

GREAT VINTAGE GORHAM SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER CRUMB REMOVER DUST PAN
GREAT VINTAGE GORHAM SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER CRUMB REMOVER DUST PAN
$9.95
Time Remaining: 4d 11h 53m
Buy It Now for only: $13.99

VINTAGE SILENT BUTLER EPC POOLE SILVER CO 75
VINTAGE SILENT BUTLER EPC POOLE SILVER CO 75
$75.00
Time Remaining: 4d 12h 8m
Buy It Now for only: $75.00

Antique Silver Plate Ornate Silent Butler Crumb Tray And Crescent Brush Japan
Antique Silver Plate Ornate Silent Butler Crumb Tray And Crescent Brush Japan
$9.99
Time Remaining: 4d 13h 50m

Vintage Wm Rogers Silver Plate Crumb Catcher Silent Butler Major Ab Adversis
Vintage Wm Rogers Silver Plate Crumb Catcher Silent Butler Major Ab Adversis
$25.00
Time Remaining: 4d 14h 38m

Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Silverplate Silent Butler Stallion dish hinged lid
Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Silverplate Silent Butler Stallion dish hinged lid
$14.99
Time Remaining: 4d 15h 29m
Buy It Now for only: $29.99

EPC 314 with crown Silver Plate Round Silent Butler with Embossed Horse on Lid
EPC 314 with crown Silver Plate Round Silent Butler with Embossed Horse on Lid
$23.99
Time Remaining: 4d 15h 55m
Buy It Now for only: $23.99

VINTAGE SILVER Co Peacock CRUMB SCRAPER  TRAY SILENT BUTLER QUADRUPLE PLATE
VINTAGE SILVER Co Peacock CRUMB SCRAPER TRAY SILENT BUTLER QUADRUPLE PLATE
$19.99
Time Remaining: 4d 16h 5m
Buy It Now for only: $19.99

Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Wood Handle Silver Plate Silent Butler
Vintage Sheffield Silver Co Wood Handle Silver Plate Silent Butler
$26.00
Time Remaining: 4d 17h 16m

1920s SILVERPLATE 2 PIECE SILENT BUTLER OR CRUMBER SET by MANNING BOWMAN and CO
1920s SILVERPLATE 2 PIECE SILENT BUTLER OR CRUMBER SET by MANNING BOWMAN and CO
$29.25
Time Remaining: 4d 18h 44m
Buy It Now for only: $29.25

C691 LOT 2 VINTAGE SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER WITH WOOD HANDLE
C691 LOT 2 VINTAGE SILVER PLATE SILENT BUTLER WITH WOOD HANDLE
$30.00
Time Remaining: 5d 1h 27m
Buy It Now for only: $30.00

VINTAGE MAJOR AB ADVERSIS SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER B ROGERS 1850 1899
VINTAGE MAJOR AB ADVERSIS SILVERPLATE SILENT BUTLER B ROGERS 1850 1899
$16.50
Time Remaining: 5d 1h 42m
Buy It Now for only: $29.50

ANTIQUE SILVERPLATE FB RODGERS SILENT BUTLER WOOD HANDLE CRUM CATCHER 1800S
ANTIQUE SILVERPLATE FB RODGERS SILENT BUTLER WOOD HANDLE CRUM CATCHER 1800S
$12.50
Time Remaining: 5d 6h 5m

Vintage F B Rogers Silver Plated on Copper Silent Butler w Wooden Handle
Vintage F B Rogers Silver Plated on Copper Silent Butler w Wooden Handle
$10.00
Time Remaining: 5d 6h 55m
Buy It Now for only: $10.00


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,